Close Menu
  • Last News
    • Cities
    • Climate
    • Energy
    • Impact
    • Markets
    • Opinions
    • Policy
    • Reports
    • Research
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

News, investigations, and analysis — our top stories every morning to start your day right.

Trending
Illustration of China's Three-Body Computing Constellation satellites performing data processing in space, generated by artificial intelligence.
“They’re Putting It in Space to Dominate”: China’s Orbital Supercomputer Leaves Global Tech Powers Scrambling to Catch Up
Illustration of a newly discovered species of giant anaconda in the Ecuadorian Amazon, created by artificial intelligence.
“We Thought It Was a Log—Then It Moved”: Record-Breaking Anaconda Discovered on Will Smith’s Amazon Expedition Shocks Crew
Illustration of the discovery of a massive gold reserve beneath China's Hunan Province, generated by artificial intelligence.
Secret Gold Megatrove Revealed: Massive $84 Billion Deposit Unearthed by Experts in One of the World’s Richest Soil Zones
Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn YouTube TikTok
Sustainability Times
Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn YouTube TikTok
Subscribe
  • Featured
  • Cities
    Illustration of Toronto's urban forest transformation with natural wetlands and diverse wildlife. Image generated by AI.

    Toronto’s Stunning Green Revolution Turns Canada’s Largest Metropolis Into a Vast Urban Forest Visible From Space

    July 1, 2025 at 4:01 PM
    Illustration of Downtown Residences skyscraper in Dubai's Business Bay area. Image generated by AI.

    “Tallest Home in the Sky”: Dubai’s 1,500-Foot Residential Tower Set to Shatter Records and Completely Transform the Urban Skyline

    June 14, 2025 at 4:11 PM
    Illustration of Egypt's ambitious Jirian urban development project featuring an artificial Nile canal. Image generated by AI.

    “Egypt’s Visionary Project Unveiled”: Skyscrapers Rising Amidst the Desert and Beside the Pyramids as Revolutionary New City Takes Shape

    June 11, 2025 at 10:00 AM
    Illustration of Saudi Arabia's futuristic Line project stretching across the desert. Image generated by AI.

    “Saudi Mega-Skyscraper Turns Deadly”: This 105-Mile Structure Threatens to Annihilate Migratory Birds on a Catastrophic Scale

    June 10, 2025 at 10:10 AM
    Illustration of Archer Aviation's Midnight eVTOL air taxi flying over Los Angeles during the 2028 Olympics. Image generated by AI.

    Flying Over LA Gridlock: These American Air Taxis Promise a Spectacular Debut During the 2028 Olympic Games

    May 20, 2025 at 4:07 PM
  • Climate
    Illustration of the New World screwworm threatening livestock and human health, generated by artificial intelligence.

    “They’re Melting Living Flesh in Hours”: Scientists Horrified as Swarm of Flesh-Eating Flies Begins Rapid Takeover of U.S.

    July 19, 2025 at 4:55 PM
    Illustration of the extreme heat wave impacting the eastern United States, highlighting climate change effects.

    “This Heat Is Killing Everything”: Apocalyptic Wave Now Suffocates Half the U.S. as Cities Burn Under Relentless, Record-Breaking Temperatures

    July 19, 2025 at 10:00 AM
    Illustration of the early beginnings of the Anthropocene and its impact on Earth's climate and ecosystems, generated by artificial intelligence.

    “They’re Erasing Us From the Timeline”: Scientists Furious as the Human Epoch Is Denied Official Status Despite Clear Start Date

    July 19, 2025 at 9:12 AM
    Illustration of the potential reawakening of dormant subglacial volcanoes due to glacial melting, created by artificial intelligence.

    “Humanity Has Lit the Fuse”: Scientists Terrified as Hundreds of Dormant Volcanoes Threaten to Explode Due to Climate Chaos

    July 18, 2025 at 6:13 AM
    Illustration of Mark Zuckerberg's superyacht, Launchpad, as a symbol of luxury and climate controversy.

    “They Call This Eco-Conscious?”: Mark Zuckerberg’s $300 Million Superyacht Sparks Outrage as Climate Hypocrisy Reaches Absurd New High

    July 16, 2025 at 6:04 PM
  • Energy
    Illustration of humanoid and quadruped robots revolutionizing shipbuilding through automation, generated by artificial intelligence.

    “They Weld Better Than Humans”: Hyundai Stuns Industry by Deploying German Humanoid Robots in Shipyard for Precision Welding Tasks

    July 18, 2025 at 8:03 AM
    Illustration of the world's most powerful floating wind turbine developed in China, capable of powering 40,000 homes annually.

    “We Built a Power Plant That Floats”: Engineers Stunned as World’s Largest Wind Turbine Lights Up 40,000 Homes Without Touching Land

    July 18, 2025 at 7:09 AM
    Illustration of Singapore's Tuas mega port poised to become the world's largest automated container terminal.

    “They’re Moving 65 Million Without Humans”: World’s Largest Automated Port Set to Rewrite the Rules of Global Shipping Forever

    July 17, 2025 at 4:51 PM
    Illustration of Deep Fission's underground micro-reactors powering data centers, generated by artificial intelligence.

    Buried Reactors, Silent Power: Deep Fission’s Radical Nuclear Plan Could Revolutionize How the World Feeds Its Data Machines

    July 17, 2025 at 3:52 PM
    Illustration of China's new maglev train reaching speeds of 373 mph, an artificial illustration.

    “They’re Not Supposed to Be This Fast”: China’s Maglev Shockingly Nears Japan’s Bullet Train Speeds in High-Stakes Tech Showdown

    July 17, 2025 at 8:49 AM
  • Impact
    Illustration of the growing use of artificial intelligence in education and its impact on transparency.

    “They Blamed the Students—But It Was Us”: Professors Caught Using ChatGPT as Secret Weapon While Cracking Down on Classroom Cheating

    July 18, 2025 at 4:10 PM
    Illustration of an asteroid on a collision course with the Moon in 2032, generated by artificial intelligence.

    “It’s Going to Shatter the Moon!”: Scientists Brace for 2032 Asteroid Impact That Could Ignite Earth’s Skies with Apocalyptic Fury

    July 16, 2025 at 8:56 AM
    Illustration of Mark Zuckerberg's luxury yacht adventure in Norway's fjords, created by artificial intelligence.

    “He Spent Millions for a Single Thrill”: Zuckerberg Crosses 5,300 Miles on Twin Superyachts, Helicopters to a Peak, and Skis Down Like No One Else

    July 12, 2025 at 9:48 AM
    Illustration of the Streetwing flying car designed by Dezső Molnár for sustainable transportation, generated by artificial intelligence.

    “Flying Car Opened Up a Whole New World for Me”: Streetwing’s Daring Design Ignites the Next Chapter in Pure Personal Exploration

    July 10, 2025 at 3:49 PM
    Illustration of a laser-based mosquito defense system neutralizing mosquitoes, generated by artificial intelligence.

    “Terrifying Death Ray Unleashed!”: China’s Laser Mosquito Defense System Annihilates 30 Bloodthirsty Pests Every Second, Astonishing Global Scientists

    July 9, 2025 at 4:00 PM
  • Markets
    Illustration of a colossal 55 billion-ton iron ore deposit discovery in Western Australia. Image generated by AI.

    Worldwide Panic as Monumental Geological Find Disrupts Global Trade and Triggers Market Turmoil on Every Continent

    June 4, 2025 at 4:53 PM

    Most sources of protein in the US contain vast quantities of microplastics

    January 11, 2024 at 5:47 AM

    Banking on change: How your accounts have climate impact

    December 26, 2023 at 7:13 PM

    Sparxell’s glitter is golden with nature-based color, design

    December 19, 2023 at 9:29 PM

    Lab-grown coffee tastes pretty darn good, scientists say

    December 12, 2023 at 10:42 PM
  • Opinions
    Illustration of the theoretical comparison between Earth's habitability and Mars' colonization prospects, generated by artificial intelligence.

    “Elon, Mars Is a Hellhole”: Astrophysicist Slams Musk’s Vision, Says Even Nuclear Apocalypse Makes Earth a Safer Bet

    July 14, 2025 at 6:12 PM
    Illustration of Millie, the 30-year-old tortoiseshell cat, enjoying a special cream cake on her birthday, generated by artificial intelligence.

    “Bottled Water Saved Her Life”: World’s Oldest Cat Millie Thrives at Age 30 by Drinking Only Premium Water, Stunning Veterinarians Everywhere

    July 12, 2025 at 5:57 PM
    Illustration of Mars colonization vision challenged by expert, highlighting Earth's superior habitability, generated by artificial intelligence.

    “Elon Musk, You’re Ignoring the Truth”: Astrophysicist’s Startling Claim—Earth Would Remain a Paradise Compared to Mars After Nuclear Apocalypse

    July 10, 2025 at 4:56 PM

    Smoke, Mirrors, and Smears: Inside the Campaign Against Gaurav Srivastava (Review)

    May 14, 2025 at 10:45 AM

    Nathan Law and the High Cost of Dissent: A Review of Targeted, Episode 3

    May 13, 2025 at 9:46 AM
  • Policy
    Illustration of a futuristic Chinese fighter jet, believed to be the J-36, soaring over a busy highway, generated by artificial intelligence.

    “They Just Flew It in Broad Daylight”: China’s Secret 6th-Gen Fighter Jet Stuns Drivers as It Soars Over Crowded Highway

    July 17, 2025 at 10:01 AM
    Illustration of China's colossal underground military command center near Beijing, generated by artificial intelligence.

    “These Images Will Keep You Awake at Night”: China’s Colossal Military Mega-Project Exposed as Satellite Photos Reveal a 1,200-Acre Fortress in the Making

    July 13, 2025 at 8:00 AM
    Illustration of a legislative debate on banning octopus farming, highlighting environmental and ethical concerns, generated by artificial intelligence.

    “They’re Smarter Than Dogs!”: Furious North Carolina Bill Launches All-Out War on Octopus Farming, Leaving Shocked Families and Multimillion-Dollar Businesses in Chaos

    July 9, 2025 at 5:55 AM
    Illustration of the Canadian government's decision to freeze Tesla subsidies amid legal controversy. Image generated by AI.

    “We’re Not Paying a Cent”: Canada Freezes $40 Million in Aid and Declares War on Tesla’s Controversial Operations

    July 7, 2025 at 4:58 PM
    Illustration of OpenAI's efforts in regulating AI for biological safety. Image generated by AI.

    “OpenAI Pulls Emergency Brake”: This Terrifying AI Showed Signs It Could Design Real-World Biological Weapons From Scratch

    July 1, 2025 at 6:10 AM
  • Reports
    Illustration of the SABRE South Collaboration’s experimental setup for detecting dark matter in the Stawell Underground Physics Laboratory (AI-generated, non-realistic illustration). Credit: Ideogram.

    “Scientists Stunned by Mysterious Light”: Bold Experiment Uses 4-Inch Glowing Crystal Core to Unveil Secrets of Elusive Dark Matter

    May 5, 2025 at 6:05 AM
    Illustration of a precision laser being fired from Earth to a satellite orbiting the Moon during daylight (AI-generated, non-realistic illustration). Credit: Ideogram.

    China Hits the Moon With a Laser: First Daylight Lunar Reflection in History Stuns Scientists and Ignites Global Space Race

    May 4, 2025 at 5:09 PM
    Illustration of the SR-72 hypersonic jet soaring through the sky (AI-generated, non-realistic illustration). Credit: Ideogram.

    “China Stunned by US Jet”: SR-72 Hypersonic Aircraft to Fly at Over Mach 5 in 2025, Triggering Shock and Panic in Beijing

    May 4, 2025 at 6:03 AM
    Illustration of China's expansive underground military command center near Beijing (AI-generated, non-realistic illustration). Credit: Ideogram.

    China Unveils Its Military Mega-Project: Satellite Images Reveal Construction of the Largest Military Hub on Earth Spanning Over 1,000 Acres

    May 3, 2025 at 6:54 AM
    Illustration of China's new amphibious anti-tank missile system on the ZTD-05 vehicle (AI-generated, non-realistic illustration). Credit: Ideogram.

    “China Unleashes Amphibious Beast”: This Armored Truck-Turned-Tank Can Now Hunt Enemy Targets Across Rivers and Swamps

    May 2, 2025 at 5:52 AM
  • Research
    Illustration of China's Three-Body Computing Constellation satellites performing data processing in space, generated by artificial intelligence.

    “They’re Putting It in Space to Dominate”: China’s Orbital Supercomputer Leaves Global Tech Powers Scrambling to Catch Up

    July 20, 2025 at 10:01 AM
    Illustration of a newly discovered species of giant anaconda in the Ecuadorian Amazon, created by artificial intelligence.

    “We Thought It Was a Log—Then It Moved”: Record-Breaking Anaconda Discovered on Will Smith’s Amazon Expedition Shocks Crew

    July 20, 2025 at 9:09 AM
    Illustration of the discovery of a massive gold reserve beneath China's Hunan Province, generated by artificial intelligence.

    Secret Gold Megatrove Revealed: Massive $84 Billion Deposit Unearthed by Experts in One of the World’s Richest Soil Zones

    July 20, 2025 at 7:57 AM
    Illustration of dolphins and orcas in their ocean habitat, highlighting their irreversible evolutionary adaptations, created by artificial intelligence.

    “They Can Never Walk Again”: Scientists Confirm Dolphins and Orcas Have Crossed the Evolutionary Line Back to Land Forever

    July 20, 2025 at 6:58 AM
    Illustration of Bacillus megaterium converting CO₂ into limestone.

    “Nature Just Did What Billionaires Couldn’t”: This Bizarre Bacteria Traps CO₂ Forever by Turning It to Stone in a Single Day

    July 20, 2025 at 6:03 AM
Sustainability Times

Why ‘mercy-killing’ wild animals is so controversial

Eirwen WilliamsEirwen WilliamsAugust 29, 2022 at 11:29 PM0
Share Twitter Facebook LinkedIn Telegram WhatsApp Email Copy Link
Follow Us
Google News
Photo: Pixabay/richardpics
Share
Twitter Facebook LinkedIn WhatsApp Email Copy Link

Photo: Pixabay/richardpics

Two wild animals that strayed from their ordinary habitats and into close proximity to humans were recently killed in high-profile cases. The life of Freya the walrus was ended by officials in Oslo on August 14 2022, reportedly because the animal posed a threat to humans.

Four days earlier, the life of a beluga whale that had strayed into France’s Seine River was ended during a failed rescue attempt.

Many people followed the whereabouts of these animals, cared about their welfare, and were shocked and saddened by their deaths. A private fundraising campaign has even been set up to erect a statue of Freya in Oslo, with its creators arguing that the walrus should not have been killed.

Although the decisions to end the lives of the beluga whale and Freya the walrus were based on different factors, they both ultimately expose the contested nature of animal euthanasia, which is often referred to as “mercy killing”.

As a researcher of animal end-of-life situations and the decision-making behind animal euthanasia, I know these decisions aren’t taken lightly. But they’re also different from case to case, informed by different ethical perspectives on the moral value of animals.

Why we disagree

Public disagreements about when animals should be killed reflect the diversity of views in society about how we should treat animals. We tend to treat wild animals differently to kept animals, for instance, and we tend to see farm animals as different from pets.

These differences are a reflection of the different bonds formed between humans and animals in different contexts. But they also reflect the three different perspectives humans take on the moral value of animals.

First, animals can be recognised for their instrumental value. In this perspective, animals are valued as a source of companionship, animal products, or knowledge gained through research. Seen as mere instruments, this perspective permits using, keeping and killing animals for the benefit of humans.

Second, animals can be valued for their own sake, for instance, because of the capacity of being sentient. In this perspective, the moral value of an animal doesn’t depend on its usefulness to humans but is intrinsic to the animal.

This means humans should respect the animal, including their welfare and integrity. Using, keeping or killing animals is consequently not permitted by this perspective unless there are strong arguments to justify these actions.

Finally, animals can be recognised as morally equal to humans. That grants animals the rights that humans have. This perspective means animals should not be used, kept or killed for human interests under any circumstances.

Although there is a trend in many societies to recognise the moral value of animals in law, there is still no consensus on how exactly we should treat animals. This explains part of the current discussion.

Ending a life

Whether or when animals themselves have an interest in the continuation or ending of their lives is the subject of an ongoing debate.

Animals are increasingly recognised as “sentient beings”. Many are understood to possess the ability to evaluate the actions of others, to remember some of their own actions and their consequences, to assess risk, to have feelings, and to have some degree of awareness.

Animals have intrinsic value as individuals. (photo: Pixabay/Mylene2401)

Despite this starting point, there remain challenges to deciding when to end an animal’s life. Because in most cases humans cannot communicate with animals, we have to rely on veterinary, animal behaviour and animal welfare science to determine if it’s in an animal’s interests to end or continue its life.

It is therefore vital that species-specific experts are involved when decisions are made to end an animal’s life. They are best placed to assess the interests of the animal, based on its quality of life and the suffering it may be experiencing.

Nonetheless, attitudes towards animal euthanasia are fluid. Freya and the beluga whale show that when animals cross contexts, in this case from the wild into human urban areas, views on how to treat them can change dramatically.

Human interests are often at play when an animal’s life is ended. These interests can be diverse, including emotional, financial and societal considerations. They can influence the final decision to end the life of the animal, or the amount of time and money we might be willing to spend on potential alternatives.

Balancing interests

When the interests of humans and the presumed interests of an animal are identified, the interests at stake are balanced to come to a final decision. In many cases, interests are conflicting. Decisions are further complicated when the public weighs in, as they’re likely to subscribe to different perspectives on the moral value of animals.

In these cases, there are no easy answers. What we learned from the recent cases is that ad hoc decision-making adds even more complexity, provides little room for reflection, and leaves the general public confused and in some cases outraged.

More comparable cases will follow in the future. An open discussion of different end-of-life strategies for animals, and the different interests of those involved, could help reduce that confusion and outrage in the future.

This article was written by Ellen Deelen, a PhD Candidate at the Centre for Sustainable Animal Stewardship at Utrecht University, and Franck Meijboom, an associate professor and head of CenSAS at Utrecht University. It is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article. 

Did you like it? 4.5/5 (30)

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

News, investigations, and analysis — our top stories every morning to start your day right.

Biodiversity Wildlife
Follow on Google News Follow on X (Twitter)
Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Telegram WhatsApp Email Copy Link
Previous ArticleRecycling EV batteries require proper solutions
Next Article What makes neighborhood-level climate action work?
Eirwen Williams
  • X (Twitter)

Eirwen Williams is a New York-based journalist at Sustainability Times, covering science, climate policy, sustainable innovation, and environmental justice. A graduate of NYU’s Journalism Institute, he explores how cities adapt to a warming world. With a focus on people-powered change, his stories spotlight the intersection of activism, policy, and green technology. Contact : [email protected]

Keep Reading
Illustration of a newly discovered species of giant anaconda in the Ecuadorian Amazon, created by artificial intelligence.

“We Thought It Was a Log—Then It Moved”: Record-Breaking Anaconda Discovered on Will Smith’s Amazon Expedition Shocks Crew

Illustration of oarfish washing ashore, known as the "fish of the apocalypse," generated by artificial intelligence.

“They’re Warning Us”: Scientists Stunned as Three Massive ‘Apocalypse Fish’ Emerge From the Deep and Wash Ashore Within Days

Illustration of the New World screwworm threatening livestock and human health, generated by artificial intelligence.

“They’re Melting Living Flesh in Hours”: Scientists Horrified as Swarm of Flesh-Eating Flies Begins Rapid Takeover of U.S.

Add A Comment

Comments are closed.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

News, investigations, and analysis — our top stories every morning to start your day right.

Trending
Illustration of China's Three-Body Computing Constellation satellites performing data processing in space, generated by artificial intelligence.
“They’re Putting It in Space to Dominate”: China’s Orbital Supercomputer Leaves Global Tech Powers Scrambling to Catch Up
Illustration of a newly discovered species of giant anaconda in the Ecuadorian Amazon, created by artificial intelligence.
“We Thought It Was a Log—Then It Moved”: Record-Breaking Anaconda Discovered on Will Smith’s Amazon Expedition Shocks Crew
Illustration of the discovery of a massive gold reserve beneath China's Hunan Province, generated by artificial intelligence.
Secret Gold Megatrove Revealed: Massive $84 Billion Deposit Unearthed by Experts in One of the World’s Richest Soil Zones
News by category
  • Featured
  • Cities
  • Climate
  • Energy
  • Impact
  • Markets
  • Opinions
  • Policy
  • Reports
  • Research
Information
  • About Us
  • Meet the Team
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Legal Mentions
  • Privacy Policy

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

News, investigations, and analysis — our top stories every morning to start your day right.

Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn YouTube TikTok
© Sustainability-Times.com. All rights reserved.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.